I would replace the control board although rather pricey.

I just wanted to update this in case anyone else had a similar problem. I ordered a replacement control board ($160) and a replacement keyboard ($60). I replaced the keyboard first because it was cheaper so I thought if it fixed my fridge I would send the control board back for a refund. Any I was right! It was only my keyboard. I left the control board alone and did not even open the box that the new control board came in so I will be sending that back for a refund. In all my internet searching (almost a full week combing through online appliance forums) I never found a video on how to change out the keypad but it was actually pretty easy. You take the panel off just as you would to change the control board, then you use your fingernails to literally peel off the keyboard (thin strip of plastic with gel on the back) and unhook it from the control board. Then you put the new keypad where the old one was and hook the new one up to the control board. I did all of this while the fridge was unplugged of course but it was still acting a little strange when I plugged it back in so I unplugged it again and when I plugged it in the second time it worked. (of course I had already tried to unplug multiple times before I ordered my keyboard to see if that is all that I needed to do but it did not work until I changed out keypad). So excited this working mother of 5 did it all myself for less than $100!:)